Metalworking underwater, especially for a primitive civilization, would be quite challenging due to the difficulties of achieving high temperatures necessary for melting and shaping metals. However, it's an interesting thought experiment. Here are a few possibilities:
Hydrothermal Vents: Hydrothermal vents are underwater fissures in the Earth's surface from which geothermally heated water issues. They can reach temperatures of up to 400°C (750°F), which is enough to melt some metals. A civilization could potentially use these vents as natural forges, although controlling the heat and handling the metals would be extremely difficult.
Chemical Reactions: Certain chemical reactions can generate heat or directly alter the state of a metal. For instance, thermite reactions can reach temperatures high enough to melt iron. However, sourcing and controlling such reactions underwater would be a significant challenge.
Electricity: If the civilization has discovered electricity, they could potentially use it to heat and shape metals. Electrolysis could be used to extract metal from ore, and electric arcs could be used to melt and weld metal. However, generating and controlling electricity underwater would be a significant challenge, and this might not be feasible for a primitive civilization.
Cold Working: This involves shaping metal by hammering or pressing it, without the need for heat. This could be done underwater, but it would only work with relatively soft metals and wouldn't allow for as much flexibility as hot working.
Biological Assistance: Some organisms are known to precipitate metals from water, effectively "mining" them. If the civilization could control and harness these organisms, they might be able to produce metal objects without the need for high heat. However, this would likely be limited to certain types of metal and wouldn't allow for the same level of control as traditional metalworking.
Comment too long. Click
here to view the full text.